Psychosocial Development and Identity Statuses

Erik Erikson and James Marcia

Erikson is the first developmental theorist to consider development in adulthood. Erik Erikson's psychosocial model of human development is often used in the fields of psychology, counseling, and education. Some specific applications include:

Erik Erikson's psychosocial model of human development has been widely studied and discussed by experts in the field, and as such, it has received both praise and criticism. Some of the ways that the theory has been praised include:

Some of the criticisms that have been raised against Erikson's model include:

It is important to note that these criticisms are not necessarily conclusive, and that Erikson's theory continues to be widely studied and discussed by experts in the field.

His theory has a development lens that considers the evolving nature of life and consciousness across the lifespan by focusing on the development of the ego as it mediates the pressures of the social world.

Erik H. Erikson's stages of psychosocial development
BYU-Idaho, Madison Harris, 2022.

General Notes

Erikson’s theory of psychosocial development:

Each stage fosters a virtue/basic strength that emerges at the end of the stage

Stage Virtue/Basic Strength… Emerges If Successfully Balanced
Basic Trust v Basic Mistrust (nonconscious sense) Hope & Drive (faith, inner calm, grounding, basic feeling that everything will be okay - enabling exposure to risk, a trust in life and self and others, inner resolve and strength in the face of uncertainty and risk)
Autonomy v Shame & Doubt Willpower & Self-Control (self-determination, self-belief, self-reliance, in confidence in self to decide things, having a voice, being one's own person, persistence, self-discipline, independence of thought, responsibility, judgment)
Initiative v Guilt Purpose & Direction (sense of purpose, decision-making, working with and leading others, initiating projects and ideas, courage to instigate, ability to define personal direction and aims and goals, able to take initiative and appropriate risks)
Industry v Inferiority Competence & Method (making things, producing results, applying skills and processes productively, feeling valued and capable of contributing, ability to apply method and process in pursuit of ideas or objectives, confidence to seek and respond to challenge and learning, active busy productive outlook)
Identity v Role Confusion Fidelity & Devotion (self-confidence and self-esteem necessary to freely associate with people and ideas based on merit, loyalty, social and interpersonal integrity, discretion, personal standards and dignity, pride and personal identity, seeing useful personal role(s) and purpose(s) in life)
Intimacy v Isolation Love & Affiliation (capacity to give and receive love - emotionally and physically, connectivity with others, socially and inter-personally comfortable, ability to form honest reciprocating relationships and friendships, capacity to bond and commit with others for mutual satisfaction - for work and personal life, reciprocity - give and take - towards good)
Generativity v Stagnation Care & Production (giving unconditionally in support of children and/or for others, community, society and the wider world where possible and applicable, altruism, contributing for the greater good, making a positive difference, building a good legacy, helping others through their own crisis stages
Integrity v Despair Wisdom & Renunciation (calmness, tolerance, appropriate emotional detachment - non-projection, no regrets, peace of mind, non-judgemental, spiritual or universal reconciliation, acceptance of inevitably departing)

See Erikson's psychosocial development theory.

Joan Erikson's 9th stage

Joan M. Erikson, who married and collaborated with Erik Erikson, added a ninth stage in The Life Cycle Completed: Extended Version.[43] She was ninety-three years old when she wrote about the ninth stage.[44] Joan Erikson showed that all the eight stages "are relevant and recurring in the ninth stage".[45] In the ninth stage, the psychosocial crises of the eight stages are faced again, but with the quotient order reversed.

Adapted from Joan Erikson Wikipedia page 5/6/2022:

This ninth stage is experienced in the eighties and nineties and is accompanied by a loss of physical health, friends, family members, and independence, in addition to isolation from society. During the ninth stage, the crisis points of the previous stages are confronted again.[18] For example, elderly adults confronting increasing physical and mental declines may lose trust in their own ability to care for themselves. They are facing a crisis similar to the trust vs. mistrust experienced in stage one.

Joan Erikson believed that during the ninth stage, older adults can shift towards a more transcendent perspective, which increases life satisfaction. She describes transcendence as regaining skills such as play, activity, and song. Most importantly, it means moving beyond fear of death.[19]

Often during this time, individuals are put into retirement communities and assisted living facilities, which Joan believed was isolating them from society and from youth.[20] She believed that "aging is a process of becoming free"[14] and should not be treated as the opposite.[20] As a result of these changes, individuals experience a loss of autonomy, self-esteem, and trust. Death is near and seen as an inevitable reality. Joan contributed to the writings on the first eight stages in the book, The Life Cycle Completed, and later added the final part on the ninth stage.[20]

Research has been done that supports Erikson’s stages.[21][22][23][24] In particular, the work of James E. Marcia on adolescence and identity supports Erikson’s crisis of adolescence.[21] Criticism of their psychosocial development theory includes that it focuses on the development of American men and excludes other groups.[25]

Maladaptations and Malignancies

Too much of either the positive or negative side of the stage results in maladaptation and malignancies respectively. Too much of the negative is generally worse than too much of the positive:

Examples Maladaption Crisis Malignancy Examples
Examples of Maladaptions and Malignancies, adapted from Personality Theories - Erik Erikson
unrealistic, spoilt, deluded Sensory Distortion Trust vs. Mistrust Withdrawal neurotic, depressive, afraid
reckless, inconsiderate, thoughtless Impulsivity Autonomy vs. Shame/Doubt Compulsion anal, constrained, self-limiting
exploitative, uncaring, dispassionate Ruthlessness Initiative vs. Guilt Inhibition risk-averse, unadventurous
workaholic, obsessive specialist Narrow Virtuosity Industry vs. Inferiority Inertia lazy, apathetic, purposeless
self-important, extremist Fanaticism Identity vs. Role Confusion Repudiation socially disconnected, cut-off
sexually needy, vulnerable Promiscuity Intimacy vs. Isolation Exclusivity loner, cold, self-contained
do-gooder, busy-body, meddling Overextension Generativity vs. Stagnation Rejectivity disinterested, cynical
conceited, pompous, arrogant Presumption Integrity vs. Despair Disdain miserable, unfulfilled, blaming

Perhaps the culminating stage of adulthood is stage seven, as stage eight is more about coming to terms with one’s life and being at peace amid disintegration. Generativity captures how generations are connected. Generations affect one another, and our church community emphasizes the chaining and linking of generations in important ways.

However, the crux and of Erikson’s theory involves identity. This stage seems to be the most central and important. Erikson’s own personal experience with identity is quite fascinating and relates to important insights about the central role of identity in development. Concerning identity, Erikson writes:

What is unique about the stage of Identity, is that it is a special sort of synthesis of earlier stages and a special sort of anticipation of later ones. Youth has a certain unique quality in a person's life; it is a bridge between childhood and adulthood. Youth is a time of radical change—the great body changes accompanying puberty, the ability of the mind to search one's own intentions and the intentions of others, the suddenly sharpened awareness of the roles society has offered for later life.[24]

Three Layers of Personality Development

Dan McAdams is a personality psychologist with a development lens who incorporates Erikson’s emphasis on identity, especially how we narrate our identities. McAdams believes that personality is composed of:

  1. Dispositions- Big Five Traits that are largely genetic
  2. Characteristics adaptation- coping skills
  3. Narrative identity

His work has focused on how adaptive narrative identity relates to generativity. As one example, he highlights the difference between life stories that are wrought with contamination sequences (e.g., Things were alright until my father would come home) versus redemption sequences (e.g., My father was a drug addict, but I am a stronger person because of it).

Think about the great “redemption sequence” that is through Christ. He redeems everything and can make everything right. He is the light of the world that enables the possibility of growth from pain; He is hope itself. He is what enables a narrative in which you are a generating figure and connected to generations; Christ enables the heights of what Erikson says is the hallmark of adult development.

Active Learning Activities

Active learning from Wikimedia Commons in the public domain

Pondering

  1. Every theory is a lens, a view, that both magnifies and overlooks. Let’s evaluate Erikson’s theory; does it provide an understanding that is helpful and useful for interacting with the world and others? Does it provide some level of prediction that is helpful?
  2. In what ways have you been able to grow from adversity? Write down a short story about how this happened. Here there are redemption sequences and the extent that those redemption sequences emerge relate to the generativity you are likely to exhibit during the culmination stage of adult development.
  3. Look at the 4 stages of Erikson’s theory that relate to adulthood beginning with adolescence and try to understand what each says about adulthood at that period of life. What are the virtues (strengths) associated with each? Do you feel like those are representative of what each stage of development?

Hidden Answer Question

Identity v. Role Confusion

Although I emphasized the first stage of Erikson’s theory as foundational, Erikson believed that adolescence was a central bridge between earlier and later stages.  

Application

For Erikson’s theory, what happens when there is a stage that is improperly balanced? How is that going to affect a person in subsequent stages? If so, what can we do about that?

James Marcia Identity Statuses

Understand and apply James Marcia’s Identity Statuses

James Marcia's Identity Statuses, adapted from Ego Identity Statuses
  Exploration
Low High
Commitment High

Forclosure:

"I've made a choice without thinking."

Identity Acheivement:

"I thought about it and I now know what I should do with my life."

Low

Identity Diffusion:

"I don't know and I don't care what I'm supposed to do with my life."

Moratorium:

"I'm thinking about what I should do."

Let’s use the term “stages” for Erikson and the term “status” for Marcia. Stage implies a sequential process, whereas status implies a framework for analyzing elements of crisis/exploration and commitment whenever there are questions related to identity throughout life.

Active Learning Activities

Active learning from Wikimedia Commons in the public domain

Pondering

  1. Every theory is a lens, a view, that both magnifies and overlooks. Let’s evaluate Marcia’s theory; does it provide an understanding that is helpful and useful for interacting with the world and others? Does it provide some level of prediction that is helpful?
  2. Consider your vocational identity. What statuses can you relate to in recent years and months?
  3. Consider other areas of your life and identity like religion and politics. What statuses can you relate to in recent years and months?

Multiple Choice

  1. Jing Yun has always wanted to please his parents, so when he got older his parents said, “No. You don’t do a job that makes you happy. Instead, you get a job that you don’t like so that you get money so you can do what makes you happy.” Even though he wanted to explore other careers, he never did and went into finance because his parents wanted him to. Which identity status best describes Jing Yun’s vocational identity?
    1. Identity Achievement
    2. Moratorium
    3. Foreclosure
    4. Identity Diffusion
  2. Which of the following statements best describes the difference between the Moratorium and Foreclosure statuses of Marcia's Identity Theory?
    1. Those at the Foreclosure stage commit to an identity without considering other options, those at the Moratorium stage explore many possible identities without committing
    2. Those at the Moratorium stage have found their identity, those at the Foreclosure stage have not
    3. Those at the Moratorium stage may one day find their true identity, those in the Foreclosure stage never will
    4. Young people are more commonly in the Moratorium stage than the Foreclosure stage

Case Study Application

  1. Rudy has changed his college major many times. Since his parents have pointedly objected to paying the expenses for tuition and room and board, Rudy has cheerfully taken on a variety of jobs, ranging from bartender to shoe salesman. He loves college, and his friends are very much the same way. Rudy's grades are generally high, though his record has some incompletes. Rudy's identity status would probably be described as
  2. Melissa’s parents are both physicians. In college she majored in French, spending a semester in France studying art and culture. Upon graduation she surprised her parents by announcing that she had applied to medical school. She has had some recent experiences with a hospice nurse and a summer job in healthcare that helped her decide on medical school. Melissa's identity status would probably be described as
  3. Lynn's mother is a professor of women's studies who is deeply involved in feminist issues. Lynn very much admires her mother, a strong woman who, as a single parent, struggled to provide for her daughter. Lynn believes that she, too, will be a strong and independent woman. She avoids people, especially men, who either don't see her in that light or try to bring out her feminine nature. She steers clear of her paternal grandmother who, although pleasant, is a very disorganized and artsy person. Lynn's college grades are very high, and her course selections reflect an unwavering commitment to politics and women's studies. Lynn's identity status would probably be described as
  4. Daniel is a first-year student at a college an hour away from home. He comes home nearly every weekend but does not really enjoy himself once he's there. He avoids talking to his parents or old high school friends, preferring to play on his phone in his room. He gets angry if his parents ask him questions about school and angrier if they patronize him. Daniel is enrolled in courses he has been told are easy, and he does not have strong feelings about his studies or his grades. Daniel's identity status would probably be described as
Previous Citation(s)
& (n.d.). Adult Development. BYU-I Books. https://books.byui.edu/-JMyB

This content is provided to you freely by BYU-I Books.

Access it online or download it at https://books.byui.edu/Adult_development/week_3A.