Classical/Operant Conditioning; Learned Helplessness; Learned Optimism

classical conditioningoperant conditioningLearned HelplessnessLearned Optimism

Major Concept Summary: Classical/Operant Conditioning; Learned Helplessness; Learned Optimism

ED 304: Ed Psych and Human Development

Author: Tegan Ross

Verified by: (Autumn Montgomery, 4 Feb), (Chelsey Berryhill, 14 July)

Disclosure: ChatGPT3 was used in the creation of this resource.

Conditioning

Behaviorism is a psychological theory that emphasizes the role of observable behavior in understanding and explaining human and animal behavior. This theory, which emerged in the early 20th century, is based on the idea that behavior can be studied and analyzed objectively, without reference to internal mental states or processes. Behaviorists argue that scientific methods should be used to study behavior and that theories and hypotheses should be testable through observation and experimentation. Furthermore, they believe that behavior is shaped by the environment, through processes such as classical and operant (sometimes called instrumental) conditioning, and that behavior can be modified through manipulation of the environment. Behaviorism has had a significant impact on the field of psychology, education, and other fields, and its principles continue to inform research and practice today.

Operant Conditioning

Operant conditioning is a type of learning in which behavior is modified by the consequences that follow it. It was first described by B.F. Skinner in the 1930s. The basic principle of operant conditioning is that a behavior is more likely to be repeated if it is followed by a reinforcing consequence, such as a reward, and less likely to be repeated if it is followed by a punishing consequence, such as a reprimand.

Skinner also discovered through one of his experiments that reinforcement was not always necessary following every display of the desired behavior. From this discovery came the understanding of schedules of reinforcement. Schedules of reinforcement refer to the timing and frequency of reinforcement (rewards or punishments) given in response to a specific behavior. There are four main schedules of reinforcement:

  1. Continuous reinforcement: reinforcement is given every time the behavior is exhibited.
  2. Intermittent reinforcement: reinforcement is given only some of the time the behavior is exhibited. This can include:
  1. Partial reinforcement: reinforcement is given for some behaviors but not for others.
  2. Extinction: no reinforcement is given for a behavior, leading to a decrease in the likelihood of the behavior being exhibited in the future.

The type of schedule used can have a big impact on the behavior being learned and how quickly it is learned.

B.F. Skinner was an American psychologist and behaviorist who is best known for his work on operant conditioning. He developed the theory of operant conditioning which states that behavior is shaped by the consequences that follow it. Skinner's ideas about reinforcement and punishment, which are central to operant conditioning, have been widely applied in fields such as education, animal training, and parenting. He also developed the idea of a "Skinner box", an experimental apparatus used to study operant conditioning in animals. Skinner's work had a significant impact on the field of psychology and also influenced the development of behavior modification, a therapeutic approach used to change people's behavior.

Classical Conditioning

Classical conditioning is a type of learning that happens unconsciously in which a neutral stimulus comes to elicit a response after being paired with a stimulus that naturally elicits the response. The best-known example of classical conditioning is Ivan Pavlov's experiment in which he conditioned dogs to salivate at the sound of a bell by pairing the sound with the presentation of food. The neutral stimulus (bell) comes to elicit the same response as the naturally occurring stimulus (food).

Ivan Pavlov was a Russian physiologist known for his work on the study of conditioned reflexes. He is best known for his experiments with dogs, in which he found that they would begin to salivate at the sound of a bell that had been previously associated with food. This became known as classical conditioning and is still widely studied today in the field of psychology. Pavlov also made significant contributions to the fields of physiology and neurophysiology. He was awarded the Nobel Prize in Physiology or Medicine in 1904 for his work on digestion.

Similarities between Operant and Classical Conditioning

Both operant and classical conditioning involve the learning of associations between stimuli and responses. Each type of conditioning can be used to explain the development of phobias, habits, and other learned behaviors. They also share the idea that the environment plays a crucial role in shaping behavior, through the manipulation of stimuli and consequences. Both theories also suggest that the processes of learning are not limited to animals or humans, but are present in all living organisms.

Differences between Operant and Classical Conditioning

Operant and classical conditioning are different in several ways. One key difference is that operant conditioning involves the modification of voluntary behavior, while classical conditioning involves the learning of involuntary responses. Additionally, in operant conditioning, the reinforcement or punishment is delivered as a consequence of the behavior, while in classical conditioning, the reinforcement or punishment is delivered simultaneously with the neutral stimulus.

Another difference between operant and classical conditioning is the role of attention. In operant conditioning, the organism pays attention to the consequence of its behavior, whereas in classical conditioning the organism does not pay attention to the consequence, it just learns the association between two stimuli.

Watch on YouTube

In summary, operant conditioning is a type of learning in which behavior is modified by the consequences that follow it and classical conditioning is a type of learning in which a neutral stimulus comes to elicit a response after being paired with a stimulus that naturally elicits the response. Both operant and classical conditioning play a crucial role in shaping our behavior and understanding of the world.

Criticisms Against Conditioning

There are several criticisms of operant conditioning and classical conditioning, which are the two main forms of learning in behaviorism.

  1. Lack of explanation for cognitive processes: Critics argue that behaviorism does not provide an adequate explanation for cognitive processes such as memory, perception, and language.
  2. Oversimplification of complex behavior: Critics argue that behaviorism oversimplifies complex behavior by reducing it to the mere response to external stimuli.
  3. Lack of emphasis on innate behavior: Critics argue that behaviorism does not sufficiently take into account innate or genetically determined behavior.
  4. Ethical concerns: Critics argue that the use of punishment and reinforcement in operant conditioning can be unethical and may lead to negative consequences for the individual.
  5. Lack of consideration of social and cultural factors: Critics argue that behaviorism does not take into account the influence of social and cultural factors on behavior.

Despite these criticisms, behaviorism has influenced many areas of psychology, and its concepts and methods continue to be used in research and applied settings.

If you would like to learn more about some critiques against conditioning, here are a few resources for your use:

https://books.byui.edu/-dgBg

https://books.byui.edu/-eAz (this article addresses what conditioning is as well as some critiques of it). 

Learned Helplessness

Learned helplessness is a phenomenon in which an individual becomes less motivated to engage in goal-directed behavior because of previous experiences with uncontrollable or inescapable events. It was first described by Martin Seligman in the 1960s when he found that dogs that were exposed to uncontrollable electric shocks later showed less effort to escape shocks in a new situation.

The concept of learned helplessness has been applied to a wide range of situations, including clinical disorders such as depression, and in explaining why some individuals may fail to take action in the face of adversity. The theory is that when individuals experience events that are uncontrollable or inescapable, they learn that their actions have no effect on the outcome, and as a result, they become less likely to engage in goal-directed behavior. Additionally, learned helplessness can lead to a negative cognitive bias in which an individual will assume that future events are also uncontrollable or inescapable. This can lead to a self-fulfilling prophecy, where an individual's expectation of failure leads to actual failure.

The phenomenon of learned helplessness can be observed in both animals and humans and has been used to explain a wide range of behaviors such as depression, addiction, and even domestic violence. It is important to note that learned helplessness can be reversed through the demonstration of controllability or the provision of an adequate coping strategy.

Watch on YouTube

Martin Seligman is an American psychologist and the founder of the Positive Psychology movement. Positive psychology is a branch of psychology that focuses on the study of human strengths and virtues, rather than just mental illness and dysfunction. Seligman's work has primarily focused on the study of happiness and well-being, and he has developed several theories and interventions aimed at promoting positive emotions and psychological well-being. He is known for developing the theory of learned helplessness, which explains how people can develop feelings of helplessness in response to repeated failure or uncontrollable events. He also developed the concept of "flourishing" which refers to a state of optimal well-being that includes positive emotions, engagement, meaning, and accomplishment. Seligman has written several books on positive psychology and his work has been influential in the field of positive psychology and has been widely studied and applied in different fields such as education, business, and health care.

Ask A Teacher

Application in the classroom:

Use a keyword or phrase to let the students know that you are refocusing the group.

  • Ex: “It’s time to switch gears now.” This is an example of classical conditioning. 
  • To decrease learned helplessness in the classroom, remind students of the potential you see in them. Let them know that you are there for them and will help them to succeed.

Learned Optimism

In contrast to learned helplessness, learned optimism is a psychological theory that suggests that individuals can learn to think optimistically and thus improve their mental health and well-being. It was also developed by Martin Seligman and, according to him, learned optimism is developed through the process of attributing the cause of negative events in one's life to uncontrollable events that we can learn from. He argues that people who make internal, stable, and global attributions for negative events are more likely to develop learned optimism than those who make external, unstable, and specific attributions. This theory can be used to improve mental health by teaching people to make more optimistic attributions to negative events, which can increase resilience and reduce the risk of depression.

Practice Quiz

1. Which of the following is a strategy to reverse learned helplessness?
  1. Increasing the frequency of uncontrollable events 
  2. Providing a sense of control over the situation 
  3. Ignoring the individual's distress
  4. Punishing the individual when they show helplessness

2. According to the theory of learned helplessness, what type of events are most likely to lead to the development of learned helplessness?

  1. Uncontrollable events 
  2. Positive events 
  3. Unescapable events 
  4. None of the above
3. At George's high school, whenever his football team got a touchdown, they would set off a cannon and everyone would cheer. One day he was at work at a construction site and someone dropped something and it made a big BANG! He suddenly felt very excited and wanted to cheer. What type of conditioning is this?
  1. Operant Conditioning
  2. Classical Conditioning 
  3. Learned Helplessness 
  4. All of the above 
  5. None of the above 
  6. Both Operant and Classical Conditioning 
4. In the question above about George, what is the conditioned stimulus?
  1. The loud BANG sound 
  2. Cheering and being excited 
  3. There is no conditioned stimulus, George exhibited operant conditioning
  4. The touchdown
5. Which of the following is an example of operant conditioning?
  1. When you shake the food box, your cat comes running
  2. When you hear an alarm on someone's phone you feel stressed and tired
  3. When you take out the trash, your mom thanks you
  4. When you hear a car horn, you feel defensive
  5. When you read the scriptures you feel the Spirit

Connections to the Classroom - Teachers

  • Operant and classical conditioning can be applied to the classroom in several ways. Here are some examples:
    • Reinforce good behavior!
    • Genuinely complimenting students on their hard work increases the likelihood of them putting in effort in the future.
    • Compliment those who are respectful during class and don’t interrupt the teacher or other students.
    • Start class with a smile!
    • Start class off with a fun activity that makes your students smile. Examples could be a funny video, a meme, or a quick game. As the school year progresses, they will associate your class with pleasurable feelings.

Connections to the Classroom - Students

Here are some ideas for how to apply operant and classical conditioning as a student:

  • Do homework at the same place and time! As you consistently do the same action in the same location at the same time, your brain will associate them together. For example, if you always do homework at your desk after school, you will start to associate your desk with homework and switch into that mindset quickly. 

**Warning: This applies to sleeping as well. When you lay on your bed, your brain associates it with sleep and automatically gets tired. That’s why it is important to do homework at a desk or table instead of your bed.

Vocabulary

A psychological theory that emphasizes the role of observable behavior in understanding and explaining human and animal behavior.

A type of learning in which behavior is modified by the consequences that follow it (i.e. reinforcers and punishment).

A type of learning in which a neutral stimulus comes to elicit a response after being paired with a stimulus that naturally elicits the response.

A phenomenon in which an individual becomes less motivated to engage in goal-directed behavior because of previous experiences with uncontrollable or inescapable events.

A psychological theory which suggests that individuals can learn to think optimistically and thus improve their mental health and well-being.

Refer to the timing and frequency of reinforcement (rewards or punishments) given in response to a specific behavior. There are four main schedules of reinforcement: continuous, intermittent, partial, and extinction.

Reinforcement is given only some of the time the behavior is exhibited. There are four types of intermittent reinforcement: fixed ratio, variable ratio, fixed interval, and variable interval.

Reinforcement is given every time the behavior is exhibited.

Reinforcement is given for some behaviors but not for others.

No reinforcement is given for a behavior, leading to a decrease in the likelihood of the behavior being exhibited in the future.

Reinforcement is given after a specific number of responses

Reinforcement is given after an unpredictable number of responses

Reinforcement is given after a specific amount of time

Reinforcement is given after an unpredictable amount of time

Summary

Classical conditioning is based on learning through association and was first described by Ivan Pavlov.

Operant conditioning is based on learning through reinforcement and punishment and was first described by B. F. Skinner.

Learned Helplessness was a psychological phenomenon first described by Martin Seligman, in which an organism learns to stop making an effort to escape or avoid a negative situation because it has learned that its efforts are futile.

A great video on operant/classical conditioning: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=H6LEcM0E0io

Video on learned helplessness and learned optimism (the flip-side of learned helplessness):

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2hHNq45rEnU

Video on positive reinforcement (personal improvement):

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=MZ9Ywl3iCpc

Happiness Advantage:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=GXy__kBVq1M

Article about learned helplessness:

https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC5141652/

Khan Academy about Conditioning - you can explore deeply into this subject and take quizzes about it:

https://www.khanacademy.org/test-prep/mcat/behavior/learning-slug/a/classical-and-operant-conditioning-article

This content is provided to you freely by BYU-I Books.

Access it online or download it at https://books.byui.edu/development_motivati/HKwnXata.